Side by side
Field elm or European white elm? How to tell them apart
Ulmus minor · Ulmus laevis
You recognise field elm by its smooth, glossy leaf with white tufts of hair underneath and by the corky ridges on its twigs; European white elm has a leaf with a softly grey-haired underside, and flowers and fruits on long, hanging stalks that flutter in the wind.
Look at the flowers or fruits: on European white elm they hang from stalks of 1–3 cm, on field elm they sit almost stalkless against the twig. Turn a leaf over: softly grey and hairy on European white elm, with only white tufts in the vein axils on field elm. Old European white elms often have plank-like buttress roots at the base.
| Field elm | European white elm | |
|---|---|---|
| Leaves | Alternate, 4–10 cm, oval to elliptic with a pointed tip, double-toothed; upper side smooth and glossy, underside with white tufts of hair in the vein axils. Very lopsided base; leaf stalk 5–15 mm. | Alternate, 6–12 cm, oval with a very lopsided base, sharply double-toothed with forward-curving teeth; upper side fairly smooth, underside softly greyish-hairy. Leaf stalk 4–6 mm. |
| Flowering | Clusters of small reddish flowers in March, before the leaves (March). | Clusters of flowers on long, hanging stalks (1–3 cm), in March before the leaves (March). |
| Fruit | Round to obovate winged fruits 1–1.5 cm long, with the seed near the top, close to the notch. | Small (about 1 cm) winged fruits with a finely fringed edge, on long stalks; the seed sits in the middle. |
| Bark | Grey-brown, furrowed lengthways into small blocks; young twigs and suckers often with conspicuous corky ridges. | Grey-brown, in thin flakes; old trunks often have burrs, epicormic shoots and plank-like buttress roots at the base. |
| Shape and height | Broadleaf tree, 15–30 m, often a shrub in hedges | Broadleaf tree, 20–30 m |
| Site | Full sun, any garden soil, normal | Sun or partial shade, any garden soil, moist to wet |
| Native to Belgium | Yes | Yes |
| Good for bees, butterflies and birds | – | – |
| Poisonous to people and pets | Not known to be poisonous | Not known to be poisonous |
| Pruning months | November–February | November–February |
The best feature in each season
- Spring
- Both flower in March before the leaves. The tiny flowers of European white elm dangle on long stalks; those of field elm form dense clusters. In April–May the fruits of European white elm, with their fringed edge, swing in the wind.
- Summer
- The leaf of European white elm is sharply double-toothed with forward-curving teeth and has a very lopsided base; that of field elm is smaller, glossier and has a longer stalk.
- Autumn
- The leaves of both turn yellow. Around a field elm there are often many root suckers; European white elm tends to have epicormic shoots and burrs on the trunk instead.
- Winter
- Field elm often has corky ridges on twigs and suckers; European white elm has none, but its bark peels in thin flakes and its buds are sharply pointed.
Where do they grow?
Both are native. Field elm is fairly common in hedges and wooded banks. European white elm is rare and grows naturally in floodplain forests and along rivers, on wet ground that sometimes floods; it is also planted as an avenue and park tree.
Which one for your garden?
- European white elm is a tree of 20–30 m for a large garden, a park or a waterside: it copes with wet soil and is much less affected by Dutch elm disease than other elms.
- As a tree, field elm is susceptible to Dutch elm disease, but it does well in a mixed hedge or wooded bank. Both are native and valuable for wildlife.
Did you know? Elm bark beetles, which carry the fungus of Dutch elm disease, avoid the bark of European white elm; that is why it survives where other elms die.
Read on
- Plant profile: Field elm
- Plant profile: European white elm
- Field elm: when and how to prune
- European white elm: when and how to prune
- Identification key
Also looks like
- Field elm or wych elm
- Chinese elm or field elm
- Field elm or Dutch elm
- Field elm or Japanese zelkova
- Field elm or field maple
- European white elm or wych elm
