Side by side

Blackthorn or hawthorn? How to tell them apart

Prunus spinosa · Crataegus monogyna

You can tell a blackthorn by its white blossom on bare, almost black branches in March–April, its small, unlobed leaves and its blue sloes; a hawthorn only flowers in May, after the leaves, has deeply cut leaves and carries red berries.

In spring the timing of the blossom tells you: white on bare branches in March–April is blackthorn, white among the young leaves in May is hawthorn. The rest of the year, look at the leaf: small, oval and toothed on the blackthorn, lobed on the hawthorn.

Blackthorn (Prunus spinosa)

Photo: Rasbak, CC BY-SA 3.0 · source

Blackthorn Prunus spinosa

Hawthorn (Crataegus monogyna)

Photo: Didier Descouens, CC BY-SA 4.0 · source

Hawthorn Crataegus monogyna

Blackthorn and hawthorn side by side
BlackthornHawthorn
LeavesAlternate, small (2–4 cm), oval and finely toothed.Alternate, small (2–5 cm), deeply cut into 3–7 lobes.
FloweringSmall white flowers, massed on the bare branches in March–April (March–April).Clusters of white, strongly scented flowers in May (May).
FruitBlue sloes with a waxy bloom; astringent, better after frost (sloe gin).Red berries with a single stone (hence monogyna, ‘one-styled’).
BarkDark, almost black, with sharp, thorny side shoots.Grey-brown; twigs with sharp thorns 1–2.5 cm long.
Shape and heightShrub, 1–4 mBroadleaf tree, 4–10 m, often a hedge
SiteFull sun, any garden soil, dry to wetSun or partial shade, any garden soil, normal
Native to BelgiumYesYes
Good for bees, butterflies and birdsYes, for bees, butterflies and birdsYes, for bees, butterflies and birds
Poisonous to people and petsNot known to be poisonousNot known to be poisonous
Pruning monthsJune–August and November–FebruaryJune–September and November–March

The best feature in each season

Spring
The blackthorn flowers first, in March–April, with small white flowers before the leaves; the hawthorn follows in May with clusters of strongly scented flowers among the leaves.
Summer
The leaf decides it: oval and finely toothed on the blackthorn, deeply cut into 3–7 lobes on the hawthorn.
Autumn
Look at the fruits: blue, bloomy sloes on the blackthorn, red haws with a single stone on the hawthorn.
Winter
The blackthorn has dark, almost black branches with thorny side shoots; the hawthorn greyish-brown twigs with true thorns of 1–2.5 cm. Sloes often still hang on after the first frost.

Where do they grow?

Both are native and grow together in hedges, copses, woodland edges and scrub. The blackthorn likes sun and forms dense thickets with its suckers; the hawthorn also grows in partial shade and becomes a small tree.

Which one for your garden?

  • Together they make an ideal mixed hedge: the blackthorn gives early blossom for bees, the hawthorn flowers in May and berries for birds, and birds nest safely among the thorns. They are food plants for dozens of butterflies and moths, such as the black hairstreak.
  • Keep the suckers of the blackthorn in check: do not plant it next to a lawn or border. Wear sturdy gloves when pruning, and do not plant hawthorn right next to fruit trees, because of fireblight.

Did you know? Sloes are sour, but after the first frost they soften and sweeten: that is when they are delicious in sloe gin or jelly.

Read on

Also looks like

Identify by feature

All species that look alike

Laden…